Old Fashioned Strawberry Pie Recipe. Dozens of Old Fashioned Recipes used in history such as pot pies, emigrant stew, gold rush pork chops, johnny cakes, desserts and more. My husband grew up on the Big Island and over there they have a Thanksgiving tradition of eating Custard Pie along with the traditional pumpkin pie and apple pie. Ground Turkey Spaghetti. Fresh berries are combined with flour, sugar and cinnamon, piled into a prepared crust, and dotted with butter. Then on goes the top crust, and the pie is slipped. Delias Oldfashioned Rhubarb Trifle recipe. Oldfashioned because when I was a child a very long time ago I used to love jelly trifles, and my mother would. A very basic, old fashioned egg custard pie from Deep South Dish blog. Growing up we had this pie every year at Thanksgiving and Christmas. Its simple but decadent. If youve never had Custard Pie before, its a little bit like Creme.