Herb Spice Chart. Make sure you have some small sterilized jars ready to go. Bring the pickling liquid ingredients to the boil in a big pan. Put the pickling marinade ingredients into. How to Make Your Own Pickling Spice. While pickling spice can be found in the canning supply or spice aisle of many stores, you may want to mix your own if you grow. We use our sweetest cracked cassia bark, lots of sweet cloves and allspice berries, and some handbroken star anise, to add a warm sweetness to the mix. Pepper. Alum for pickling is not a specific product. Yogurt Bread. Rather, there are many other uses of alum. Some pickles recipe handed down from your grandmothers call for the usage of.